Stitch Pics Home page

Copyright

A brief unofficial Guide to UK Copyright Law

Copyright became statutory in the UK with the passing of the copyright act 1911. The current act is the copyright, designs and patent act 1988.

Copyright law gives the creator of literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works, sound recordings, broadcasts, films, and typographical arrangements of published editions, rights to control the ways in which their material may be used. These rights cover

In many cases the creator will have the right to be identified and credited and object to distortions of his / her work

Copyright is a given right and does not need to be claimed or registered. The presence or absence of copyright symbols or notation does not affect the rights in anyway.

Proof of authorship or if applicable ownership may be required if legal procedings are undertaken. Duration of copyright is at present 70 years after the death of the owner. Transfer of rights from desceased owners are subject to litigation and subsequent ownership. Certain rights may be given to owners of artistic works which in themselves have expired copyright especially if financial gain is made from the display or usage of them. International conventions give copyright protection in most countries subject to national laws. Exact restricions vary from country to country.

Copyright applies to many areas including literary, music, art, and so on. For the purpose of this site we are concerned only with

  1. Copying, Specifically related to cross stitch charts and kits
  2. Popular Characters & Registered Trade Marks Whether such things can be made into Cross Stitch
  3. Design Right Naming and Authenticity of objects or designs.
  4. Intellectual Rights Relating to composition and photography
This list is not, by intent, comprehensive or exhaustive. The intention is to highlight issues relate to the cross stitching comunity.

Copying

In its simplist form copyright law prevents unauthorised copying. This includes This includes photocopying of a chart for ease of sewing. Although most designers will not object to the practice of making a copy to sew from, it is a concession not> a right.
Copyright also restricts passing on or reselling a chart once you have used it. A kit or chart is sold to allow one person to stitch it once.
If you repeat a design, or pass it on you are in effect duplicating it
A kit or chart may only be re-sold if it is in the same condition as when purchased. To sell a chart from a kit after completion is a breach of copyright
Selling a finished design may also be deemed breach of copyright in as much as the designer may consider thay have a right to a proportion of the revenue.

Popular Characters and Registered Trade Marks

Popular charahters include those from litterary sources, Film, TV, Comic Books and so on.
This includes Names such as "Gollumn" or "Hobbit" (J R Tokien) even if there is no actual picture to compare it to. Using the name is a breach of copyright and acknowledgement is in itself not enough, the writer is entitled to renumeration for his creation's use.
Designs of such characters need specific permission, usually in the form of a license. This license may well have time limit after which permission is no longer given. Items created during the license period are usually allowed to be sold after the license expires.

Registered Trade Marks are the property of individuals or companies who have paid for the right of exclusive use.
Registered Trade Marks Include

It should be noted that

We asume that similar restriction would apply to Foreign military or sporting symbols or badges dependant on local law

Design Right

Design Right is primarily a UK right, not transferable abroad unless specifically patented or agreed.
Design right does not apply to any stationary item that is on free public view but may be invoked for objects within restricted or paid for areas. Specific architectual designs may still qualify for design right status.
Design Right is an intellectual property right which applies to original, non-comonplace designs of the shape or configuration of products. Design right is not a mononopoly right but a right to prevent copying and lasts 10 years after first marketing the product subject to an overall limit of 15 years from creation of the design. Design right may be bought, sold or licensed.

This right is primarily concerened with 3 dimensional objects such as cars, vacuum cleaners, even buildings. Two dimensional objects such as wallpaper do not qualify but are protected under normal copyright. The grey area is where an object becomes so comonplace that it looses it's design right. It may be sufficient just to acknowledge the designer, but in doing so you are opening yourself up to the possibility of claiming Intellectual or design right compensation. The designer is making a living from their creation and as such can claim monetary recompense from someone else making money from it. Economic constraints and legal wrangling prevents most people from asserting these rights but the existence should be noted and a cross stitch may be withdrawn without notice should the question of design right or copyright be brought by an interested party. Of course if a badge or logo is included in the design and then reproduced then the question of Registered Trade Marks arises. (see above)

The Main problem occurs if a company or individual actively markets their design in different media from the original such as in the form of toys or gifts. When such marketing occurs it is more likeley that they would take an interest in a craft like cross stitch and expect some sort of payment for it's image to be used.

A car is designed. Most of the important parts are internal but the shape is aesthetic and an intergral part of the design. Many cars are marketed for their shape or configuration. It could be argued that selling a cross stitch of a specific car design is a breach of design right. In reality most manufacturers consider any publicity to be good publicity and as long as the picture does not defame or damage the reputation of the company they will overlook any rights they may have. Once the vehicle is on sale and being driven there could be argument that it is in the public domain. The owner of the vehicle has bought the right to display it so takes the design rights for himself. The net result is that the company or designer has lost this exclusive right by selling it in large quantities.

Incidentally, in the USA human faces are considered the property of their owners and to photo or reproduce them can be subject to financial constraint or renumeration. This right is not transferable to our knowledge but may mean that we are not allowed to market or sell certain designs to the USA.

Claiming Authenticity for a design increases the likelyhood of a claim being made as you are implying that the designer approves of your reproduction which may well not be the case. For something to be deemed authentic it must be confirmed to be a good reproduction by someone with the authority and knowledge to be able to make judgement. Stitch Pics never claims authenticity unless it has been given by the designer or copyright holder specifically.

Intellectual Rights

Intellectual rights are primarily concerned with composition and imagery. A Robin cannot by definition be copyright but a picture or photograph of one can. The rights are concerned with the composition, light, angle and use of componants to form the picture. Reproduction in any form, mechanical or otherwise is prohibitted. Even drawing or other human impression, if it is faithful to the original is a breach of copyright.

Intellectual right also include the use of copyright or design right objects in a photograph or composition. If the content of the picture is primarily concerned with an item of copyright material then that is considered a breach of copyright.

For this reason postcards, greetings cards (of subjects that would not normally be considered copyright) and other photographs in books or on loan may not be translated into cross stitch without the permission of the owner or copyright owner.

On the same basis a cross sttch design may not be "redrawn" or copied, or reproduced in any way even if the original is no longer available for sale. Copyright exists even if the owner is not attempting to make financial or other use of it.

Conclusion

There is much complaint about the cost of cross stitch kits and specifically the absence of chart only packs for designs. The fact is that designers and manufacturers are in business and need to be able to recoup both designing and material expenses plus the cost of selling (advertising, wholesale, shops etc). By breaching copyright or attempting to obtain charts from other sources you are not only breaking copyright law, you are also jeapordising the existence of the companies and designers concerned and in the same way increasing costs which means higher prices. Financial constraint and ecoconomics means that often a chart pack is not commercially viable: i.e the revenue does not match the development cost or the cost of sale. Such is life and we have to abide by it not circumnavigate it. Judicial costs and other financial constraints may make it impractical to prosecute copyright infringements in many cases this does not mean that copyright should be ignored or willfully violated.
Please do not ask us to reproduce copyright material as a refusal may cause offence

Back to top

Useful Links

UK Goverment Web Site
Intellectual Propert Rights
Patents

These guidelines are our interpretations of UK Copyright Law.
Stitch Pics cannot be reponsible for actions taken from this page without consultation with proper legal advice.
Anyone wishing to dispute Stitch Pics rights to use any picture,design or other content should first Contact Stitch Pics